Search  
Tuesday, January 06, 2009 ..:: Forum ::.. Register  Login
 HomePage Minimize

 Print   

 Products Minimize

 Print   

 MSRS Minimize

 Print   

      
 RoboticsConnection Forum Minimize
SearchForum Home
  Discussions  Serializer Robot Controller  Communication w...
 Re: Communication with Serializer via XBee(TM)/XBee-PRO(TM) serial interface
 
 8/22/2007 5:26:40 PM
ringo
36 posts


Re: Communication with Serializer via XBee(TM)/XBee-PRO(TM) serial interface

Yes Xbee is radio.

yes Wifi is Radio.

there is no way that I know of to make 1 talk to the other. they each have thier own frequency, modulation scheme, etc.

Ringo

 


Ringo Davis, Hardware Technical Lead RoboticsConnection.com
 8/22/2007 6:09:52 PM
Umesh
12 posts


Re: Communication with Serializer via XBee(TM)/XBee-PRO(TM) serial interface

Thanks for Reply.

As per the details on net both Xbee(http://www.maxstream.net/products/comparison.php) and wifi(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WiFi , http://www.moonblinkwifi.com/2point4freq.cfm) supports 2.4GHz Frequency.

So where is the point of gap/difference in communicating with eachother ?

 

Thanks,

Tharanath umesh.

 8/22/2007 6:14:54 PM
ringo
36 posts


Re: Communication with Serializer via XBee(TM)/XBee-PRO(TM) serial interface

They are just 2 different technologies. You can buy a cordless phone that works at 2.4Ghz as well but that does not mean you can hear your WiFi on your phone. Even if some super RF engineer could figure out how to modify an Xbee to receive and transmit WiFi, the serilaizer would still not work. It looks for a simple serial stream.

Ringo

 


Ringo Davis, Hardware Technical Lead RoboticsConnection.com
 8/22/2007 7:53:20 PM
jywilson
35 posts


Re: Communication with Serializer via XBee(TM)/XBee-PRO(TM) serial interface

Ringo is correct.  In addition, the Xbee data protocol (mostly likely based on the ZigBee standard) is very different from WiFi.  The radio modulation is also very different. 

The data protocol is the defined standard for how the data will be arranged to facilitate communciation between the sender and the receiver.  The radio modulation describes the manner in which the RF signal will be altered in time to represent a bit of data.  The only commonality may be the one you discovered, in that they both operate in the same unlicensed frequency spectrum of 2.4 GHz. 

If you are reluctant to buy another Xbee device for your laptop or PC to communicate with the Serializer, you could always purchase a Bluetooth USB dongle and the Bluetooth module for the Serializer.  They are many low cost Bluetooth dongles available these days, and you could use it to connect to other (non Serializer) Bluetooth devices.  Just a thought.


James Y. Wilson
http://www.learningce.com
Fortudine Vincimus!

 8/23/2007 10:57:28 PM
Umesh
12 posts


Re: Communication with Serializer via XBee(TM)/XBee-PRO(TM) serial interface

Thanks for more information Jywilson

Thanks,

Tharanath Umesh.

  Discussions  Serializer Robot Controller  Communication w...

SearchSearch  Forum HomeForum Home    Print   

Copyright 2004-2007 Summerour Robotics Corp   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement
DotNetNuke® is copyright 2002-2009 by DotNetNuke Corporation